“ The pizza here is the best I've had. I really recommend the Detroit or Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. Always fresh and delicious and quick. ”

“ The most amazing pizza and only garlic knots, which where so yummy, I have eaten since my Celiac diagnosis. I'm told the regular menu items were delectable as well. The service was outstanding. We will definitely be back/ ”

“ Donatina never disappoints. They have many options, a small parking lot and the service is always good. A must try: Ceasar salad and the Chicago style pizza. Add hot honey to the pizza and you won't be disappointed! They have both quick booth seating or dining room seating with service to the tables. ”

“ Donatina produces some really good Neapolitan with very reasonable prices. There were also a lot of slices with good toppings. We got the caption and pistachio. So unique and tasty. We loved every bite. It was good enough for 2. The freshly crushed pistachio really added to the flavor and crunch. Service was great too, felt very welcomed. ”

“ After Newsday gave a glowing review of this cafe, my husband and I took a drive over to visit. First, the young man who makes the pizza is worth the visit alone. He diligently rolled out the dough, tossed it up like a pro, cut it into perfect circles and then added the necessary toppings with great care. He had to put the pizzas into the beautiful wood fired oven, carefully watch several at a time, take them out, cut and then package them quickly. He deserves a raise!! (he mentioned only doing this for 6 mos. The server was very pleasant and the pizza was delicious. We'll be back. ”

“ This place does pizza the right way. They do pizza all styles, which is a daunting task, but they rise up to the challenge. I'm a huge wood fired guy, and they didn't disappoint. My margherita came out with a thin crisp crust, no flop and the ingredients were fresh and flavorful. The sauce was tangy and the mozzarella was light with no grease in sight. I don't have to go to the city anymore for quality brick oven! ”

“ Came to Donatina for the first time during COVID when it was takeout only and was happy to return again to see it in full swing this past weekend. Solid casual pizza spot with indoor and outdoor seating, and a beer and wine list. They're known for their Detroit-style slices which were delicious, but the stand out to me was their grandma pie. Perfectly crispy on the bottom, light and airy on top. I also ventured out to try one of the more inventive pizzas, a chipotle chicken slice. It was flavor heavy for sure, an interesting thing to put on pizza but it kind of works? Service was prompt and friendly. We decided to sit at the counter so we had a view of the pizzas being made in the large wood burning oven. I wish I had been hungrier or came with a bigger party to be able to try more of what they had to offer! Will definitely be back again. ”

“ I finally tried this pIzzaria from seeing on social media and I wanted to try the pepperoni Detroit style pizza and it was simply the best pizza's I have ever tried deep dish wise. I loved the decor and layout of the restaurant. The place is very clean and Kira is very polite and gave me a lemon for the Pelegrino water I got. The cheese pizza pie was good as well. My family had a great experience. I ordered the cheese filled garlic bread but they gave me garlic knots. I didn't mind though. I'll definitely will be coming here to pick up more pizzas from now on. I just wish you delivered instead of door dash. ”

“ So clam pie was here all along and I had no idea! Pro tip: Ask for bacon on it. According to my husband, who grew up here, this use to be a 7-11 or something. The trip down memory lane happens every time we are in the area and I may be mixing the stories up, but what I'm trying to say is Donatina a must visit in an every growing hot spot. Small dining area, but works nonetheless. Menu is incredible. In addition to the clam pie we ordered garlic knots, pizza fries with crumbled sausage, the Detroit and the meatball with the ricotta pie. Beer and wine along with soda are found in the fridge. I had a Pumpking. Also in the fridge you with fine the Cake Boss desserts. You know your girl took home the chocolate cake! The boy loved his cannoli and after we cleaned him up and packed up the rest of the delicious pizza we couldn't finish we headed home. I'm all seriousness, we really enjoyed everything we ordered. The crust was cooked perfectly in the amazing and gorgeous pizza oven which is the focal point for the restaurant. Looking forward to trying more pies for sure! ”

“ New to Patchogue I needed to find good pizza! Yelp brought me here. What a delicious slice of pizza! And the pepperoni is real pepperoni where it "cups." I didn't know this was a thing until recently. The dough itself and the crust had great flavor! I saw they offer it on their menu to add Mike's Hot Honey. I had some at home and added it and it was a delicious marriage of flavors. It was also cheaper than we normally pay for a pie with pepperoni. My boyfriend and I agreed it was very yummy and this is our new go to pizza place! They one a pizza my heart. ”